Add Visibility Transparency for Creators

@d2fl @grok No, that’s not my argument. It feels like it’s weighted before it’s posted, and my point is that at that stage, it should be based on interaction and the merits of the post, rather than weighting people’s first replies on other factors like following or similar metrics.

@MaryBowdenMD @X @nikitabier @Safety X censors

dear @nikitabier fix your shtty algo at this point it's pretty clear it's not just about content quality or replies one day a post takes off in minutes the next day it's only in my dad and sister's timeline it's a billion dollar company do something jeez

@MaryBowdenMD @X @nikitabier @Safety “Freedom of reach not speech”. Fancy way of censoring us! Elon is just as bad as the rest imo, trust at your own peril.

@MaryBowdenMD @X @nikitabier @Safety What the fuck is an "inauthentic behavior"?

@THeNBLeNDr @MaryBowdenMD @X @nikitabier @Safety I looked it up too, and Grok said appeals are almost always handled by algorithm, so if it's mistaken, it's extremely hard to get a human to look at it.

@elonmusk the algorithm overhaul is overdue. Gifted creators are posting into the void while mediocre content trends. TBG has a song that could inspire millions — but visibility shouldn't depend on who you know. If 𝕏 is truly the global town square, let the best voices be heard. 🎤🙏🏼 🎧 t.co/VbxrEPF8T1 Cc: @nikitabier

@MaryBowdenMD @Amothersanthem @X @nikitabier @Safety What’s considered an “inauthentic behavior” and what specific researched peer reviewed criteria determines it? This appears to be censorship from the outside looking in.

I'm glad I looked to make sure. Just keep a low profile for now is what I find best regardless of what @X tells you. Usually it goes away within 48 hours. Also, Hey @X @Support etc, please stop ghost banning people just for reacting to things. You want engagement? We're giving it to you and yet you continue to punish people.

Yes. And folks like us would appreciate it if @X's algorithms stopped suppressing the voices of the people by its thumbs on the scales, imposing designated celebrity accounts on us, instead. Hello @nikitabier, @elonmusk, @XDevelopers, did you notice how Twitter functioned before 2015?

@MaryBowdenMD @X @nikitabier @Safety What’s going on with this censorship?

เหมือนจะดี แต่ถ้ายังเป็นแบบนี้อีกต่อไปแอคเล็กน่าจะท้อและทยอยหยุดแอคทีฟกัน แล้วก็จะกลายเป็นลูกโซ่ไปกระทบแอคใหญ่ในท้ายที่สุด It seems good, but if this continues, smaller accounts will likely become discouraged and gradually stop being active, which will then create a chain reaction affecting larger accounts in the end. I hope you will take this advice into consideration and make improvements. @nikitabier

@nikitabier how does engagement stay low every time? There is an unfavorable algorithm here that needs to be looked at. t.co/cLC7eFzTDd

@elonmusk @karpathy @kuroke01 @gallabytes Please overhaul the non-existent support too! @nikitabier t.co/60nBC0PIHJ

I'm not seeing posts which are worth a bookmark like earlier in X. All posts are mostly related to payout, impressions, followers, wishes, let's connect, etc. Thanks to @elonmusk @nikitabier Please increase the standards of X! by leveraging AI to stop posting this stuff. X value is more than payout and impressions.

@nikitabier X feels very different these days. My timeline is full of random videos, and I'm seeing less of the content, discussions, and news that kept me engaged. When monetization becomes the primary goal, it attracts the wrong audience; pushes qlycontent to the sidelines.

Main trouble with populism is that the loudest voices get the biggest audience. An algo which heavily boosts daily activity and axes you from feeds when you break a streak does not represent a population with work to do, companies to build, and families to nurture. At times, we just have better things to do than posting in algo-optimized patterns. Then current x-algorithm punishes a real life much more than former versions. @elonmusk @nikitabier seams like a good time for an overhaul.

.@nikitabier when are you going to fix the inauthentic behavior suspensions and the subsequent appeal system? t.co/fWhNe6NgG2

I just had a thought and I’m going to hound everyone and anyone on X until someone explains how it would not work. @nikitabier visibility score. Inform everyone of their visibility score. Think how you already rank CMs. Craft rules around visibility. Be transparent. Content that will show on ‘For You’ or replies. My issue is and this has been my problem with the platform for a very long time is that it rewards those with the most followers instead of those providing original content in all ways. From original posts to original invocative replies. It rewards those pumping out content instead of rewarding those that provide quality content. And this account is not an example. I gave up. My first Twitter account was 2008. And I can prove it. I had accounts that grew to thousands of followers and then were suppressed. I no longer try. I don’t have a full Team to pump out content. So I reply now and then when I feel like it.

@KarlM55102 @X @nikitabier I get no reach It’s crazy

@nikitabier X has no appeal process for a shadowban btw

@nikitabier Please fix the algorithm. I was ghosted for posting good content. You probably won’t see this comment.

Hey @elonmusk Remove this me no like football Cc @nikitabier

This is exactly why @elonmusk and @nikitabier need to rethink the payout system. When views become the goal, people start posting content like this just to game the algorithm. Reward quality, not engagement farming. I know you'll say this is your view, but not even a killer justifies killing. You poor soul, I genuinely pity you. I'll pray that God shows you a better path before you go any deeper down this one.

Privacy suggestion for @X @Safety Add a user option to hide or make optional device type and approximate login location shown in profiles/activity. These are sensitive data; not all users want them public. An opt-in/opt-out control would improve privacy and user control

@nikitabier @elonmusk 4. The @Support account can no longer be tagged or DM’d. 5. Buying Premium on an alternate account and DMing @Premium doesn’t work. 6. Tagging Nikita or Elon in a post is obviously a futile effort 7. Posting on dev community website results in the thread being locked

Inauthentic behavior suspensions continue. Just look at the flood of new posts: t.co/k9KTBbHrUh t.co/nRXRINOlqf As usual, nobody at X cares. @nikitabier only cares about publicly dunking on "creators", @elonmusk is busy making cat AI. t.co/fWhNe6NgG2

@elormkdaniel @nikitabier please if you can restrict profile image download or screenshot for x to prevent scammers and fake impersonators

X की लंका लगा दी @nikitabier ने वाहियात के बदलाव कर डाले , ना चलाने में मजा आ रहा है , व्यूज का घोटाला हो रहा है। अरे भाई इसको पहले जैसा कर दो , नहीं तो फिर वहीं पहुंच जाओगे जहां से शुरू किया था @elonmusk @x @XCorpIndia

Would love to get video replies on Android @premium

@CreasonJana @elonmusk @nikitabier Truth. The numbers and reach have been abysmal over the past two months. The idea of posting is for reach and to gain a following. It's practically non-existent.

@JoelleAdler @X @nikitabier This is so disappointing @elonmusk we thought X was the town hall of the world and our voices are being silenced. :(

Hey @elonmusk and @nikitabier when did you decide to morph X back to old Twitter? A lot of us are noticing … t.co/j2EVTdy5Vz

hard shilled ticker once and I am shadowbanned the same people spam tickers all the time and I can't NOT see their posts how does it work @nikitabier @elonmusk ?

@QueenBFashionW @nikitabier Subscription Everything in life now is paid for.

@FcbManuel_8 @nikitabier This has to be your annual impressions Monetization impressions count within 3 months

@Techie_OluDave @elonmusk @nikitabier A lot of people are experiencing the same thing. If there was a rule violation, clear communication would go a long way. Users deserve to know exactly what happened and how to resolve it.

@STILL_LOUIE @nikitabier @elonmusk @elonmusk @X Thousands of Iranians trusted X because it promised free speech. Iranian dissidents and pro-Israel voices are being suspended while legitimate questions go unanswered.If speaking against dictatorships gets you silenced, what exactly makes this a free speech platform?

@caviterginsoy @steipete @nikitabier Because you just read this one page newspaper and don’t doomscroll infinite timeline. If that would work well, i myself certainly just block my twitter and will only use it via this simplified UI

@nikitabier please do malicious blue badged accounts next 🙏🏾. t.co/Zy2uMgtvth

Dear @nikitabier I joined X because of it's authenticity for news, facts and figures and now there are accounts like this boldly churning out false news and narratives just for a few bucks. This isn't what was promised. t.co/TSrmhlgC9Y

@Giooton @nikitabier CT is waking up We can't have X showing Charts and not give CT more visibility 🤷🏽

@JoelleAdler @X @nikitabier @elonmusk, why are you censoring accounts that are critical of @JDVance

@LilyRoslynWest @nikitabier It's as far from free speech as you can get. I wrote a single boring article about Qatar and Iran social media strategy. Suppressed almost immediately, and permanently. X is owned by Qatar, not Elon.

500 Verified साथी, पर Reach पर ग्रहण क्यों? 📉 उत्तर प्रदेश की शिक्षा, राजनीति और सामाजिक मुद्दों पर बेबाकी का इनाम मिला—672 में से 500 Verified Followers पूरे! असीम आभार! 🙏 लेकिन एक कड़वा सच देखिए (Photo में)... ये पिछले एक हफ्ते का Data है। Followers बढ़े, लेकिन Impressions 13.5K पर अटक कर -24% 🔴 गिर गए। क्या @X , @elonmusk और @nikitabier द्वारा छात्र हितों की निष्पक्ष आवाज़ को दबाया जा रहा है? यह कारवां रुकेगा नहीं। इस लाल निशान को हरा करने और Mission 1000 Verified Family के लिए आपके Support की सख्त ज़रूरत है। 👇 इसलिए, इस आवाज़ को दबने न दें, Repost करके अपनी ताकत दिखाएं! 🤝 #X #StudentVoice #YouthPower #RoadTo1000 #SupportEachOthers

Je travaille ce matin à l’analyse de SpaceX et plus généralement de l’industrie spatiale. Je ne posterais pas mon podcast sur X a cause des restrictions régionales voulues par X et pas @nikitabier. C’est dommage. Je vous mettrais le lien en commentaires .

@seagullshah @elonmusk @nikitabier X is 💯 blocking free speech. Constantly limiting my account for supporting Lion & Sun revolution

Why has Alex started a campaign against those who criticize you? These are the same people who supported @POTUS when he attacked Iran and attended rallies. People from all over the world that the President himself reposted. This is appalling. Why are you so afraid of criticism? Now you have Alex silence them? No one should criticize you? Is this turning to another Biden admin? A new account can’t have an opinion simply because you don’t like it? We thought you told Europeans that free speech is important or is it until they disagree with you. @LauraLoomer @pdoocy @nikitabier @elonmusk @marcorubio

@Devon_Eriksen_ @nikitabier I've been talking about this. Don't need it to be quite as granular as you suggest but I would like that: t.co/nARsZEiTwS t.co/zDxUbDBXMB

@nikitabier @ElijahSchaffer Can you do one for people that do copy and paste from chatGPT??

Yo @nikitabier Highly doubt you see this but worth a shot since I tag you many times Can you explain why the reach is down by almost 90% for most people? This applies for micro accounts like me and big accounts too - though for me I don’t care personally but good to know t.co/6H2k1vi9jW

@YokaiCapital @nikitabier It’s across everywhere. Reach down by almost 90% But it is what it is. For micro accounts like me doesn’t matter. But people with your size are defo rekt

@X @premium @Support @Nate_Esparza @mike_rosinsky @nikitabier @elonmusk @Engineering It does seem suspicious. The impressions appear unnatural, and I have concerns that traffic may be coming from outside X through coordinated bot activity. If bad actors are artificially inflating impressions or engagement, it could potentially be used to manipulate platform systems and create problems for targeted accounts. I hope X investigates the source of this traffic and takes appropriate action against any coordinated bot networks involved.

@a5medv @nikitabier @grok I reviewed his account and even though he did reposted an image in several languages as clickbait, shouldn’t X have a built-in algorithm to cope with this, so the repeated content is demoted? I reviewed his account and it doesn’t appear to be AI Slop or spam.

Im a little scared of this approach , imagine a grandmaster analyzing a chess game while showing the same video or pictures , but posting it a a day later than someone who just copy pasted the video first without any added value. I could say the same about many other things, I hope this approach doesnt punish someone that spend a lot of time analyzing things and posting late

@nikitabier @McDonaldsXBT Transparency would be nice. Tell the X people of the pending or incoming change "before" it occurs. Sigh.

@kglightspire @RobertMSterling @nikitabier It could also flag users who do this even once and give their future posts special attention. (Since I'm guessing it's only a certain kind of person who does this kind of shit.)

@Devon_Eriksen_ @nikitabier Important I'd say to reward a wide variety of good content. Perhaps both the long, thoughtful analysis and the meme capturing the news of the day, and everything in between. Incentives determine outcomes, because humans tend to adapt their behaviors to what is actively rewarded.

@nikitabier Where is X's transparency? Even Google, MGID, and Meta have earnings dashboards. What is the reason for this?

This is simply almost a game with the creator who puts his effort all the time. It is simply reprehensible and unacceptable. Evaluate your monetization mechanisms, I have earned by 8M views what I have invoiced with 1M. It is a complete embezzlement, even though my statistics in all aspects were higher.

@nikitabier @striedinger @mnmityushkin @k3shen @singhai @alexabraham This is simply almost a game with the creator who puts his effort all the time. It is simply reprehensible and unacceptable. Evaluate your monetization mechanisms, I have earned by 8M views what I have invoiced with 1M. It is a complete embezzlement, even though my statistics in all aspects were higher.

@nikitabier This is one of the biggest inconsistencies. Monetize 223 USD, equivalent to 1 million impressions in 8 million. Nobody understands the X payment system. @nikitabier

@DANNYonPC @StokeyyG2 @nikitabier that might make sense if my tweeting patterns changed drastically between the two periods, but they didn’t i’ve been done leaking for both periods, with a 50% decrease in the second period for some reason they increase for some people in certain periods, then the opposite

@erenfromtargets @nikitabier you need to fix the payout system, almost the exact same impressions as last payout term and i got >50% less lol

@BerryYNWA1 @nikitabier X under Nikita is like a regime. They punish one without showing specific violation post.

@nikitabier alright I’ll bite. Why is it so much easier for Reddit to RELIABLY contain all of your posts on your profile at once [even gaiaonline from 15 years ago was great with this] but this Superapp can’t make that happen? Make that a premium feature

@nikitabier What about neglected X creators? People are abandoning the platform because payouts are a fraction of what they were.

Many thanks, Ryan! Yes, that is what I don’t understand… I have a REAL audience and I interact with them directly and we have legit NFL & NBA discussions exactly the way ‘X supposedly wants’ yet the new model rejects all of my legit hard work, it is totally depressing @nikitabier @grok @X @premium @Support @XDevelopers

@nikitabier Hey Nikita how about you hire some Android engineers because the Android experience rn is spotty

@nikitabier What happened to X payouts?

Dear @nikitabier and @elonmusk Small update from the front lines. Since yesterday, some of my posts and replies have started receiving attention, engagement and actual human interaction. Which naturally raises an important question. Will your world-class algorithm now conclude that a 10-year-old account with 63 followers has suddenly evolved into a sophisticated international engagement-farming operation? Because if that is the case, I would first like to congratulate myself. I was previously unaware that I possessed the resources required to run a global bot network. For the record: • 10 years of account history • 63 followers • One Premium subscription • Zero secret headquarters Just a guy posting on the internet. I will continue asking this question every day until one of two things happens: Either someone answers it. Or my account disappears. At least then I will finally have clarity. Regards, A REAL HUMAN. And if there is still any doubt about that, my phone number is already verified with X. You can call. I promise I sound exactly like my tweets. 😄

Hello All, Please like and repost if your views are aligned with me regarding algo. Hello @x @nikitabier , There is a lack of transparency and adequate support on X. We follow the rules, invest significant time in creating content, and then suddenly see our reach collapse without any clear explanation. This leaves creators frustrated and uncertain about what went wrong. The algorithm needs greater transparency and a more balanced approach to content distribution. At present, it often appears to reward high-volume reply activity more than original content creation. Greater weight should be given to the reach, engagement, and quality of original posts, while reducing incentives for repetitive reply farming. Creators would benefit from clearer communication about account status, visibility changes, and the factors affecting reach. Greater transparency would help build trust and encourage higher quality content across the platform.

someone plsss explain me this!! past few days it’s looks like my post are not even going on feed @nikitabier can we show something like why it’s not visible that much? If there is any other issue like spam or report any issue?? this doesn’t make sense

@ishiguzochris @nikitabier @X A lot of creators just want clear rules so they know what game they're playing.

Since Elon Musk has put this x updated change on hold. “We will pause moving forward with this until further consideration” Creators on x haven't gotten any feedback from @nikitabier and his beautiful @x team what coming new on the revenue sharing incentives to better reward the content we want on X:

@orbitant @nikitabier same same my friend... premium plus with a few dozens views on 1000 words posts... If you want to laugh you can check how many views I will get with the post I just published on the same topic right now.

@petranto Thanks 🙏🏻 … Yup. X algo is completely broken … it’s okay, not here to make a living from its miserable payout. In fact, I’m contributing by subscribing the highest plan. @nikitabier couldn’t be bothered that small paying accounts are being penalized. 😂

@nikitabier Am with you. Wish could heavy up some posts that are important among this morass and noise.

@katty36091 @nikitabier Is removing of followers real thing?

Beyond the Eclipse: Mass Reporting and Platform Manipulation Deliberate manipulation through coordinated report lists, offline applications, or bots can silently push a smaller account into near-zero reach with no warning or visible flag. These organized efforts often bypass normal protections and hit smaller accounts particularly hard. To the weekly cowards running the lists: I see you. You can’t debate, so you report. You can’t answer a direct question, so you silence. That’s not strength — that’s the lowest form of cowardice. Bottom Line: This isn’t about disagreement anymore. It’s about control. As to me: Harleys wobble, but they don't fall down! ~snerk~ I’ll be over here doing what I’ve always done. So throw a leg over and let's go, I got a story to tell you. And no, I don't care what you ride, the road is just as hard, and the wind is just as cool.🏍️ Just come on... #follow @sbs_1969 Harley McDude😎and the HM Meme Team! #flhrc #bigflakeblue #lonewolf #noclub #nocolors #nobatwing! 😆😆😆 @x @Support @elonmusk @xai @CensoredMen @ShadowbanTest @lindayaX

Great job from X Recently I've been getting a lot of tweets with just 50–100 views in my feed Nice to see smaller accounts finally getting some visibility @nikitabier

What are you doing about racism against INDIANS by south asian pakistani and Bangladeshi accounts as well as chinese who fund it on X @nikitabier t.co/g0qSctT0X5

@nikitabier No - Don’t be so over confident EVER Policies and execution decides the fate of a platform!!! Like ChatGPT seems to be trailing big time now You have biased policies around countries like India, Nikita and that’s the bitter truth

@alexxortv @Gigabear_X @nikitabier @elonmusk it pisses me off. these people use this advantage and raid straight related content with death threats. And if they get reported, they never get banned

This is why X is god awful. Too many people spewing hate and Naz* propaganda. Watch as nothing will happen to this tweet. @nikitabier are tweets praising Naz*s are okay? t.co/i9N62V6joZ

@nikitabier Good, then finally remove the ability to lock comments. Either its a free speech platform or it isnt. Not being able to comment on someone spreading lies is not free speech.

@nikitabier Then tell me why am I paying for this again? I get the same number of views as someone who doesn't pay.

@nikitabier Remove the spam bots first idiot.

Vừa lướt bên "phây bút" thì thấy cũng có trường hợp dừng chia sẽ doanh thu. Nhưng nền tảng đó cung cấp rõ lý do, cũng như các video hoặc bài đăng nào có vấn đề. Tôi hi vọng X cũng sẽ làm được như vậy để người sáng tạo hiểu và khắc phục dễ hơn, @nikitabier ! Đó mới là cách để X trở thành nền tảng mà mọi người sử dụng. @elonmusk